My Office's Listings

Some or all of the listings below are provided by the ERA Carroll Realty Co., Inc. office.
$4,500,000 (USD)
Active

Turkey Tree Minor Area Single Family Home

Active

2899 Big Horn Avenue Sheridan, WY 82801

4 Bed
5 Baths
5362 sqft
MLS# 25-451
Welcome to your dream sanctuary, where the harmony of nature meets sophisticated living! This immaculately maintained 4-bedroom, 4.5-bathroom home is a rare gem on a productive pasture, boasting an impressive 1,100 lineal feet of Little Goose Creek and valuable water rights. Picture waking up each day enjoying Wyoming wildlife. As you step into this secluded paradise, you are greeted by a craftsman's touch, evident in the solid custom-made doors and elegant built-ins throughout the home. An abundance of windows invites natural light in the spacious interiors while offering breathtaking views of the lush surroundings from every angle. The heart of this home is undoubtedly its stunning eat-in kitchen, where culinary dreams come alive and ample space for family and friends to gather. Imagine hosting an evening cookout that flows effortlessly onto the gorgeous patio. For moments of relaxation and entertainment, retreat to the dedicated theatre room, where movie nights transform into cinematic experiences in the comfort of your own home. Need to focus or work from home? The private office offers a quiet haven, allowing you to balance productivity with peaceful living. Each of the four spacious bedrooms is designed with your comfort in mind, featuring its en-suite bathroom for enhanced privacy and convenienceperfect for families or when hosting guests. Beyond the exquisite interiors, this property is free from city covenants, just minutes from a coffee shop, grocery stores, schools, and churches. Envision weekends spent by the stocked 1-acre pond or riding your horses across the vast cross-fenced pastures. With a sprawling 6,700 sq. ft. shop, you'll have all the space you need to accommodate your hobbies, vehicles, and RV, while a 1,600 sq. ft. hay barn ensures you have all the necessities for your equestrian friends. This exceptional property is more than just a home; it's a lifestyle opportunity. All measurements are approximate.
Listing Courtesy of SHERIDAN COUNTY / Listed By: Pinnacle Home and Land Group, ERA Carroll Realty Co., Inc.
$1,900,000 (USD)
Pending

Big Horn Area Single Family Home

Pending

45 Kruse Creek Road Big Horn, WY 82833

3 Bed
2 Baths
2064 sqft
MLS# 23-66
There is a recent bank appraisal at $2,600,000. This reduced price of $1,900,000, is for a fast closing by 10/1/2023. Sellers will also owner finance for one year with good down payment, terms to be determined. Welcome home to this established 40-acre horse property located in the heart of Big Horn, Wyoming's thriving polo community, just 1.5 miles from the world class polo fields. This expansive property is unlike any other, set against the backdrop of the beautiful Big Horn Mountains. The home and immediate yard are nestled in a secluded park-like setting with cottonwoods above and the bubbling sound of Kruse Creek that runs through the property, setting the perfect scene for morning coffee or sunsets on the covered front porch. The historic three bedroom, two bath home was built in 1920, and while it has been updated over the past century, many of the original details have been kept intact, including the original rock fireplace, doors and windows. The warmth of the deep brown craftsman style trim and maple wood floors enhance the main living space, including the formal dining room, where you will also find a grand bookcase which is a relic from the Sheridan Carnegie Library. Each of the three bedrooms are located on the upper level where you will find an original built-in bookshelf in each one and decorative designs on their wood floors, continued illustrations of the historic charm of the home. The paved driveway was designed with convenience and low-maintenance in mind, and at the curve of the turnaround sits a 900 sq ft, 2-stall detached garage that is deep enough to fit two long bed pickups and still has plenty of room for additional storage.

As a long-standing horse property, it boasts several amenities that will allow you to create your own equestrian heaven, including a 6-stall horse barn, corrals, fenced riding arena, and three pastures, all with water access. There are also two supplementary barns and two sheds for additional livestock use and equipment storage, and all but one have electricity, making nightly tasks a little bit easier. To top it all off, there is an irrigated hay meadow that produces approximately 20+ tons of hay annually, and a 28'x32' hay barn to store it in.

There will never be a lack of water on this luscious parcel with one house and two stock wells, the spring-fed Kruse Creek which runs year-round, and long-standing documented water rights that remain with the property. Because of the natural habitat that has been preserved on this property and those around it, you won't have to look far to find plenty of native wildlife. Simply look out your window or walk out your back door and be greeted by a variety of animals including deer and wild turkeys, just to name a few. It's perfect for the wildlife watcher and hunter, alike, and for those who enjoy marksmanship, there is a gun bay for safely discharging firearms without disturbing the wildlife or the neighbors.

With the property already conveniently ready for your horses, the low maintenance of the steel exterior home, and the close vicinity to the Big Horn polo fields, this would make the perfect property for year-round or seasonal polo players! All measurements are approximate.
Listing Courtesy of SHERIDAN COUNTY / Listed By: Jane Clark, ERA Carroll Realty Co., Inc.
$649,500 (USD)
Active

South Park Area Single Family Home

Active

357 Coffeen Avenue Sheridan, WY 82801

3 Bed
2 Baths
2860 sqft
MLS# 26-569
This extraordinary home, featured in Old House Journal, is being offered completely turnkey. Every carefully selected fixture, beautiful period lamp, historic furnishing, curated artwork by well-known artists, and thoughtfully chosen décor will remain with the home, allowing the next owner to simply step in and enjoy this beautifully restored and preserved piece of Sheridan history. Walk in, pour yourself a cup of coffee, and settle right in--there is no need to purchase a spoon, towel, lamp, television, artwork for the walls, or even a cozy quilt, because it is all already here, carefully selected to complement the warmth and historic charm of the home. Built by George Herbert Benham in 1915, who worked for the Bighorn Lumber Company, this remarkable residence has been thoughtfully refurbished and restored to its original glory as a historic City of Sheridan structure. Step inside to a welcoming open floor plan filled with beautiful original woodwork and trim. Timeless details include charming window seats, a telephone niche, and warm, inviting living spaces rich with historic character. Mission and Craftsman-style lighting fixtures were thoughtfully selected throughout the home to complement the architecture and preserve the authenticity of the period. Antique period hardware can be found throughout the home, further enhancing the historic character and attention to detail woven into every space. The kitchen honors the home's history while offering modern convenience, featuring a restored 1934 Magic Chef stove, a 1931 GE Monitor Top refrigerator, and a Fisher & Paykel drawer dishwasher discreetly hidden behind custom wood panels. The original cabinetry remains intact and has been carefully restored, while the kitchen backsplash features classic subway tile that complements the historic character of the home. In keeping with the commitment to preservation, each of the 46 windows has been individually removed, repaired, and reglazed to maintain the integrity and craftsmanship of the property. An inviting eat-in breakfast nook complements the kitchen, creating the perfect space for an early morning cup of coffee, while the formal dining room, complete with the original built-in buffet, lends itself to more elegant gatherings and entertaining. The bathrooms continue the historic charm of the residence, featuring carefully selected period pieces, including beautiful clawfoot tubs that reflect the elegance and craftsmanship of the era. A huge basement offers endless possibilities for additional living space, hobby areas, or simply exceptional storage capacity. Even the outdoor landscaping has been thoughtfully designed to reflect the historic era of the home. The front yard features native, low-maintenance landscaping supported by a drip irrigation system, blending beauty with practicality. A one-car garage is complemented by ample additional parking access from the alleyway, offering flexibility for extra vehicles, guests, or recreational storage. Enjoy this extraordinary property as your private residence or continue operating it as a charming and successful historic Airbnb destination. This is a rare opportunity to own a fully restored and thoughtfully curated piece of Sheridan history. Please ask the listing agent for a complete document outlining all upgrades and restoration work completed on the home, along with a personal property inventory list detailing the items that will remain with the property. Additionally, please request copies of the Old House Journal. All measurements are approximate. https://benhamjohnstonbungalow.com/
Listing Courtesy of SHERIDAN COUNTY / Listed By: Pinnacle Home and Land Group, ERA Carroll Realty Co., Inc.
$454,900 (USD)
Active

Coffeen 2nd Area Single Family Home

Active

835 Olive Street Sheridan, WY 82801

3 Bed
2 Baths
1824 sqft
MLS# 26-518
This beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home has been extensively remodeled down to the studs, blending modern improvements with comfortable one-level living. Conveniently located close to town and within walking distance to the park, this property offers the perfect combination of function, charm, and flexibility. The spacious kitchen was completely remodeled in 2018 with new subflooring, cabinetry, countertops, and backsplash, while the inviting living room features updated insulation and sheetrock with new flooring, trim, and custom built-in shelving added in 2025. The front entry was fully renovated with new insulation, tile flooring, trim, closet, and front door, and the back entry was transformed into a practical mudroom and oversized pantry.
Major updates continue throughout the home, including remodeled bedrooms, an updated laundry room, a beautifully remodeled bathroom in 2022 with additional flooring updates in 2025, and a custom master addition completed in 2016 by Shannon Haar.
Outside, you'll love the lovely privacy-fenced backyard, brand-new backyard deck, covered patio space, sprinkler system, and additional parking for an RV, boat, or camper. The oversized 3-car shop/garage provides incredible storage and workspace opportunities. Another fantastic feature is the additional detached space perfect for a man cave, she shed, hobby room, workout area, art studio, or private retreat. Move-in ready and meticulously improved over the years, this property offers peace of mind, exceptional storage, and the ease of updated one-level living. Ask for the full list of updates and improvements! All Measurements are approximate.
Listing Courtesy of SHERIDAN COUNTY / Listed By: Pinnacle Home and Land Group, ERA Carroll Realty Co., Inc.
$449,500 (USD)
Active

Sheridan Area Single Family Home

Active

78 St Hwy 335 Sheridan, WY 82801

3 Bed
2 Baths
2293 sqft
MLS# 26-611
A little bit of country charm with the convenience of being just minutes from town. Situated on a spacious 1/2-acre lot with no covenants, this 3 bedroom 2 bath home invites the perfect combination of comfort, functionality, and beautiful mountain views. From the moment you arrive, you'll appreciate the peaceful setting, open space, and versatility this property provides. Inside, the home features generously sized bedrooms, multiple living spaces, and a thoughtful layout designed for both everyday living and entertaining. With the large family room, there is plenty of room for relaxing evenings, hosting guests, holiday gatherings, or simply spreading out and enjoying the extra space. A dedicated office provides the perfect setup for working from home, a hobby room, study space, or additional flex area to fit your needs. The remodeled and expanded open-concept kitchen is truly the centerpiece of the home. Designed with both style and practicality in mind, it offers an abundance of cabinetry, extensive counter space, and exceptional storage throughout. Whether you love to cook, entertain, or simply appreciate an organized kitchen with room for everything, this space delivers. The open flow into the dining and living areas creates a warm and welcoming atmosphere filled with natural light and beautiful views of the surrounding mountains. All measurements are approximate.
Outside, the property continues to impress. The oversized 3-stall garage/shop features large overhead doors and a convenient walk-through door, making it ideal for vehicles, recreational toys, equipment, hobbies, projects, or additional storage. With no covenants, you'll enjoy the freedom and flexibility to truly make the property your own.
This home offers the rare opportunity to enjoy a little extra elbow room, gorgeous scenery, and a country feel without sacrificing convenience to town. It is absolutely not a drive-by property--it's a must-see to fully appreciate the size, layout, office space, storage, views, and overall value this property has to offer. Priced to sell and ready for its next owner to enjoy everything it has to offer. All measurements are approximate.
Listing Courtesy of SHERIDAN COUNTY / Listed By: Pinnacle Home and Land Group, ERA Carroll Realty Co., Inc.
$429,500 (USD)
Active

Story Area Single Family Home

Active

59 Fish Hatchery Road Story, WY 82842

3 Bed
2 Baths
1543 sqft
MLS# 25-931
Nestled in the enchanting mountain town of Story, Wyoming, discover your personal retreat on a stunning secluded acre, where the whispering winds and rushing water create a symphony of tranquility. Experience the convenience of main-level living, where every corner radiates warmth and comfort. Enter into a welcoming space designed for both relaxation and functionality. A spiral staircase leads you to a charming upper-level hideaway, perfect for guests or a delightful playroom for kids. Imagine creating art, crafting memories, or simply unwinding in your personal sanctuary. For those who enjoy the outdoors, this property is equipped with a reliable irrigation system provided by Prairie Dog Water Supply Co, ensuring that your lush surroundings thrive. The oversized one-car garage offers ample space for your vehicle, while additional outbuildings provide extra storage, accommodating all your hobbies and outdoor gear. Close to the Story Store, Library and Post Office, making it as convenient as it is inviting. With the majestic mountains as your backdrop, relish in the peace and serenity that this property offers, all while being part of a vibrant community. Whether you seek a year-round residence or a seasonal getaway, this home promises a lifestyle filled with adventure and relaxation. Embrace the beauty of Story, Wyoming, and make this captivating property your own. Your mountain dream awaits! All measurements are approximate.
Listing Courtesy of SHERIDAN COUNTY / Listed By: Pinnacle Home and Land Group, ERA Carroll Realty Co., Inc.